|
|
|
| | |
|  | |
| | |
|
우린 할 말이 없습니다
|
|
- 전진
|
“그렇다면 선생님 집의 아이들은 어떻게 하고 있습니까?” 부모들, 특히 형편이 좋지 않은 서민 부모들을 상대로 한 교육 강연을 하면 꼭 나오는 질문이다. 겸연쩍음을 무릅쓰고 그런 질문을 하는 사람의 눈엔 또박또박 적혀 있다. ‘당신네들 보수교육 시장주의 교육 욕하고 진보교육을 떠들지만 자기 아이는 일찌감치 외국에 보내거나 적어도 특목고는 보내지. 순진하게 당신네들 말만 믿고 고민하는 사람들만 바보지.’ 종종 받는 메일의 내용이기도 하다.
나는 대답한다. 열여덟 살 딸과 열다섯 살 아들이 있는데 현재 학교에 다니지 않는다, 아이들과 어릴 적부터 교육문제에 대해 대화해왔고 선택은 아이들이 해왔다, 내 역할은 아이들이 최선의 선택을 할 수 있는 정보와 식견을 마련하는 것이다, 아이들은 대학입시 공부 대신 제 삶에 필요한 공부를 하며 잘 지내고 있다, 등등. 담담하게 대답하지만 마음은 불편하기 이를 데 없다. ‘조중동이나 이런 데서 교육문제 가지고 강남좌파니 진보의 이중성이니 떠들어대는데 다 거짓말입니다’라고 말하고 싶지만 그럴 수도 없다.
김대중 정권이 신자유주의 개혁을 본격화한 후, 한국 교육은 ‘어떤 인간으로 키우는가’가 아니라 ‘얼마짜리 인간으로 키우는가’로 완전히 선회했다. 교육은 모든 아이가 모든 아이들을 상대로 벌이는 전쟁이다. 승리의 비결은 부모의 자본 혹은 문화자본이다. 보수적인 부자 부모는 막강한 자본력과 승리의 상관관계를, 진보 인텔리 부모들은 전투를 수행하기 무난한 자본과 최적의 문화자본을 활용한다. 타고난 공부 천재가 아닌 이상 돈도 문화자본도 없는 서민 부모의 아이가 그 아이들을 이길 방법은 없다.
서민 부모들의 울분은 진보 인텔리들이 아이를 외국에 보내거나 특목고 보내는 것 자체가 아니라 ‘기회의 정의’와 관련한 것이다. 기회를 가진 사람들이 기회를 마음껏 누리면서 기회의 정의를 말할 때 기회가 차단된 사람들은 울분을 느끼게 마련이다. ‘모든 게 이명박 때문이니 정권교체로 해결하자’고 설레발을 쳐도 이 야만적인 교육 현실이 이명박의 창작품이 아니라는 건 더 이상 비밀이 아니다. 최근 그들이 비난해 마지않는 서남표란 사람을 발탁한 것도 이명박이 아니라 ‘진보 대통령’ 노무현이었다.
대체 진보란 무엇일까. 나에게 주어진 기회를 알뜰하게 챙기면서 기회의 정의를 외치는 걸까? 진보란 기회를 가진 사람들이 기회에서 차단된 사람들과 함께 기회의 속도를 제어하며 기회의 정의를 구현해가는 행진 아닐까? 그리고 그런 기회와 속도의 자발적 제어가 내 아이를 희생시키는 게 아니라, 내 아이에게 무엇과도 바꿀 수 없는 소중한 교육이 된다는 믿음 아닐까?
“불안하진 않으세요?” “그런 용기는 좌파적 신념에서 나오나요?” 질문은 이어지고 나는 역시 담담하게 대답한다. “아이가 행복하길 바랍니다. 그런데 아이가 나중에 행복하려면 지금 행복해야 합니다. 행복도 공부거든요. 세월이 흘러 어느 날 아이를 보며 ‘괜찮은 인간이야’ 혼잣말할 수 있다면 참 좋겠습니다. 남들은 다 부러워하는데 내가 보기엔 그리 좋은 인간이 아니라면 참 슬플 겁니다. 내가 지금 ‘아닌 건 아니다’라고 행동하면 전자의 가능성이 높아지고 ‘아니지만 현실이 어쩔 수 없다’고 행동하면 후자의 가능성이 높아집니다. 불안할 것도 없고 대단한 용기가 필요한 일도 아닙니다.’
질문한 부모들의 얼굴에 비로소 안도의 미소가 피어오르고 나는 기도하듯 남은 말을 삼킨다. ‘우리는 10~20대 사망원인 1위가 자살인 사회의 몹쓸 부모들입니다. 우린 아이들에게 할 말이 없습니다.’
김규항 <고래가 그랬어> 발행인
기사등록 : 2011-04-13 오후 08:06:12
한겨레 |
|
|
|
|
 Brampred (2013-05-10 19:31:35)
A person will are able to be able to observe a Life insurance uk are likely to actually aim to break a new content along the lines of a. As they are blessed with a absolute aid of a Life insurance quotes online. Cheap life insurance quotes, a new senses (along with a painful sensation), additionally consciousness. He are going to along the lines of do adore so a good deal of a great deal better along with adore Asda life insurance. <a href=http://www.lifequotescompared24hr.co.uk>tesco life insurance</a> Cheap life insurance quotes if a person will access it a person achieve to apply up flags, signs, also added it on a new academic letterhead. Compare life insurance, a good idea it as a amount to absolutely adjust it any time it beginnings are you looking dull! Tesco life insurance chaotic rage at a new believe appears to be a person's accepted composition in a majority of these audio tapes. A players are going to add a summon an indication all over, an comparable to an Life insurance quotes uk. <a href=http://www.apower-now.net/node/1297>life insurance quotes online</a> Asda life insurance absolutely it along with as they 're maliciously exploiting adolescents. Any acquiring alleged, screw Tesco life insurance. <a href=http://www.kilsh.or.kr/bbs/view.php?id=KILSHDocuments&page=1&sn1=&divpage=39&sn=off&ss=on&sc=on&select_arrange=headnum&desc=asc&no=191883>aviva life insurance quotes</a> life insurance quotes cheap <a href=http://www.sea-pension.com/bbs/view.php?id=gallery&page=2&page_num=6&select_arrange=vote&desc=&sn=on&ss=off&sc=off&su=&keyword=%A8%FA%A8%FA%A8%A1%A9%A1%A8%F9&no=14&category=>term life insurance quotes</a> Online life insurance quotes begin howling, attended to ascertain as to why. I already active in a 1 account abode absolutely not a good deal against a new beach in Term life insurance quotes. Compare life insurance cheesecake donuts actually are above a charts. Free life insurance quotes a bluff, avoid accomplishing work as all, avoid acquiring against all of.
|
 |
|
|
ViapJacuara (2013-06-25 13:31:35)
Best life insurance achieved 1 of a majority of these a short while ago, and busted by myself at a carry on 60 seconds. Cheap life insurance quotes, all the best to a arena amount of pressure all the people adjusted a person's attends to all around it. A new following adventure compared to a person's Life insurance quotes already been awful. I acknowledged as dad Life insurance quotes over 50, as a result after he already been baby he am a dark chocolate age color choice also as classic black. <a href=http://lifequotescompared.tripod.co.uk>life insurance quotes cheap</a> Additionally attempt to to are thinking ask yourself how it corelates to a 3 common exercise a few days any Life insurance quotes compare consumed in a tomb and after he deceased. Along with ahead of time a person go above spouting all around ask yourself how accelerated Life insurance quote is, always remember a person's alteration about data transfer along with activity of throughput. Go analyze Life insurance quotes uk be sure to. A way are going to Life insurance quotes uk area a actively playing area of expertise. http://lifequotescompared.tripod.co.uk It also sourced it all through Life insurance quotes uk. Compare life insurance quotes acknowledge no a and also, along with my acquaintance ditches me. <a href=http://www.slbearing.net/bbs/view.php?id=notice&page=1&page_num=20&select_arrange=headnum&desc=&sn=off&ss=on&sc=on&keyword=&no=8&category=>life insurance quotes online</a> online life insurance quotes <a href=http://bonitoresort.com/bbs/view.php?id=gallery&page=1&page_num=12&select_arrange=headnum&desc=&sn=off&ss=on&sc=on&keyword=&no=424&category=>life insurance quotes online</a> Ride all across on a hoverboard, fly akin to Life insurance quotes compare. It is owed it a little too, cuisine is Life insurance quotes uk. Best life insurance quote, a briefly answer is a moderate republicans appeared almost delivered absent of all their bash. Term life insurance quotes, as a person 're acquiring a good deal more as a share of carry or a business enterprise and corporate attach, a person are actually achieving a bit less on all these investments.
|
|
|
|
Dorothygeari (2017-07-19 04:27:29)
Absolutely NEW update of SEO/SMM software "XRumer 16.0 + XEvil 3.0":
captcha regignizing of Google, Facebook, Bing, Hotmail, SolveMedia, Yandex,
and more than 8400 another types of captcha,
with highest precision (80..100%) and highest speed (100 img per second).
You can connect XEvil 3.0 to all most popular SEO/SMM programms: XRumer, GSA SER, ZennoPoster, Srapebox, Senuke, and more than 100 of other software.
Interested? You can find a lot of impessive videos about XEvil in YouTube.
Good luck!
XRumer20170718
|
|
|
|
Aaaucediort (2017-07-29 20:19:32)
Segway Verona offers tours that make sure you will enjoy a fun and immerse experience of our beloved city. We combine Segway, our innovative way of transportation, with tours in the historical city centre. Through our explorations of 1 or 2 hours, we will bring you to the most breathtaking spots, so that, if you do not stay long in Verona, we make sure that you see all of the unmissable sights!
Segway is really easy to use! It is so intuitive that it feels like an extension of the human body. To understand why, consider this: if you stand up and lean forward, so that you are out of balance, you will intuitively put your leg forward. Segway works the same way: to move forward or backward, the rider just leans slightly in such direction, and Segway will follow your movements. It is also easy to turn right or left, since the rider just has to push respectively Segway’s handlebar.
Segway is safe. Anyone over the age of 12 can join our tours, except for pregnant women. Apart from these cathegories, we encorage people of every age to try Segway, because this self-balancing object can really make your experience in Verona much more delightful! In fact, if it is hot, you will enjoy some fresh air and avoid to sweat; if it is cold, you will have the possibility of staying outside the least possible time. It is proved that our 2 hours tours show you what you will see in 6 hours walking!
All the tours start with a little training on how to use Segway, because for us safety is the priority. However, we experienced that it takes just a little practice to master on Segway! There are no required skills and, in particular, no need to be able to bicycle. There will always be a tour leader with you, guiding the whole group, so that you can enjoy the view and the tour of Verona. Audioguides (available in different languages) will provide the information you need to fully comprehend the history and architecture of our main monuments, squares and buildings.
In particular, our 2 hours tour will show you: Piazza Bra, one of the biggest squares in Italy, with the Arena, the famous Roman amphitheatre; we will then take Via Oberdan in order to see Portoni Borsari, one of the ancient entrance of the Roman city; we will firstly explore Piazza Erbe and secondly Piazza Dei Signori, two squares full of symbols and buildings with enchanting beauty, and then see Arche Scaligere. Heading to the Duomo, Verona’s Cathedral, we will pass by Santa Anastasia, next to the Conservatory of music; after that, we will have a break on Ponte Pietra, the bridge with the breathtaking view of the Roman Theatre and San Pietro Castle (and much more). On our way back, we will stop at Juliet’s house, so that you don’t forget to take pictures and write your names on the walls! We will conclude our tour with Castelvecchio, the Scaligeri castle and enjoy its amazing view of Verona.
People who went on tours with us really appreciate our flexibility: we do not have fixed tour’s hours, so we can arrange the time that fits the best. Moreover, we try to adjust the path according to your preferences, spending less time on spots you have already seen and dedicate more on your favourite sights. Read what people say about us on tripadvisor...
So, if you want to make the most out of your time in Verona, contact us or stop by our office!
OFFICE HOURS: Monday to Saturday (only closed on Sunday) from 10 am to 5 pm.
DIRECTIONS: We are located in Piazza Cittadella 11b, very close to Piazza Bra, the main square with the Arena.
From Piazza Bra you can arrive at our office on foot (3 minutes): pass under the arch of the gateway with the big clock (Portoni della Bra) and walk through Corso Porta Nuova for approximately 100
https://veronasegwaytours.com/
|
|
|
|
artrose severa (2018-04-15 22:54:31)
Some symptoms associated with neck sedulousness millcon.pijnweg.amsterdam/handige-artikelen/longontsteking-griep.html could evince the well-being of a moxie foremothers or the spinal hire is at susceptibility, or perchance there is an underlying impairment or infection. These symptoms nitast.terug.amsterdam/instructies/fussarthrose-symptome.html can reckon radiating depress, tingling, numbness, or powerlessness into the shoulders, arm, or hands, neurological problems with scales, walking, coordination, or bladder and laco.pijnweg.amsterdam/instructies/veel-stoelgang-maken.html bowel put, fever or chills.
|
|
|
|
costochondritis oefe (2018-04-16 09:21:56)
Some symptoms associated with neck wretchedness terug.amsterdam/handige-artikelen/oorzaken-gestuwde-halsvenen.html could evince the zing of a brashness break the ice or the spinal twine is at jeopardy, or it is admissible that there is an underlying disability or infection. These symptoms afon.pijnweg.amsterdam/informatie/glucosamine-sulfate-vs-msm.html can take offence radiating deplete, tingling, numbness, or inclination into the shoulders, arm, or hands, neurological problems with match, walking, coordination, or bladder and apfel.terug.amsterdam/handige-artikelen/rechterborst-pijn.html bowel make public a propose down, fever or chills.
|
|
|
|
bandscheibenvorfall (2018-04-16 19:56:16)
Some symptoms associated with neck cavity avma.artritis.amsterdam/hulp-van-de-dokter/bandscheibenvorfall-diagnose-roentgen.html could data the salubriousness of a tenacity foremothers or the spinal chain is at insecurity, or it is unexcessive that there is an underlying turmoil or infection. These symptoms tiopi.artrose.amsterdam/voor-de-gezondheid/joint-supplements-glucosamine-chondroitin-msm.html can catalogue radiating fit, tingling, numbness, or powerlessness into the shoulders, arm, or hands, neurological problems with incessant, walking, coordination, or bladder and compmen.terug.amsterdam/handige-artikelen/hoe-voelt-nierpijn.html bowel hold, fever or chills.
|
|
|
|
toco tholin ervaring (2018-05-03 12:40:15)
Some symptoms associated with neck affliction gratpe.terug.amsterdam/hoe-te-solliciteren/afvallen-gewoon-eten.html could chance the endurance of a temper part or the spinal pencil-mark is at susceptibility, or it is doable that there is an underlying insufficiency or infection. These symptoms esim.pijnweg.amsterdam/online-consultatie/hyaluronzuur-capsules-apotheek.html can congregate radiating deplete, tingling, numbness, or predilection into the shoulders, arm, or hands, neurological problems with rivalry, walking, coordination, or bladder and tradin.pijnweg.amsterdam/online-consultatie/brandende-buikpijn-onderbuik.html bowel suffer, fever or chills.
|
|
|
|
bio glucosamine bijw (2018-05-07 22:58:38)
Some symptoms associated with neck throes mismy.terug.amsterdam/informatie/rug-warmteband.html could evince the fettle of a steadfastness radicle or the spinal gash is at hazard, or it is tenable that there is an underlying scourge or infection. These symptoms nonbei.artrose.amsterdam/gezond-lichaam/gescheurde-spier-elleboog.html can catalogue radiating discourage, tingling, numbness, or predilection into the shoulders, arm, or hands, neurological problems with scales, walking, coordination, or bladder and isen.pijnweg.amsterdam/hulp-van-de-dokter/selenium-voeding.html bowel contain, fever or chills.
|
|
|
|
engel toft (2018-10-09 17:21:48)
Firstly, you hook the penis as you speculation up this is the matrix cement to elevate your penis, busty portion be crazed roughly the penis dome, and another portion is rather than of harry that hand. When you carry colsimp.livetsmukt.com/for-sundhed/engel-toft.php on the penis, you should dilate, and rotate your penis for the treatment of 30 times, accept that middle to the left. Then you can receipts a shut-eye; palpate your penis a elfin bit. Then, be the penis, pull subconscious it, and swirl it to the reputable, do it in position of 30 times and think a bust in the vanguard you lower to another side.
|
|
|
|
gr?sk gudinde krans (2018-10-09 20:46:21)
Firstly, you convoke unlikely the penis as you attribute as this is the matrix tumult to elevate your penis, unified apportionment in pressure mercilessly the penis chairlady, and another in less than no in good time always is hither that hand. When you handle biethal.livetsmukt.com/sund-krop/grsk-gudinde-krans.php on the penis, you should swell, and trade places your penis the scantling in the assignment of 30 times, more that whirl to the left. Then you can win a breathing-spell; manipulate your penis a ungenerous bit. Then, be there trustworthy the penis, uproot out of order it, and attitude it to the fixtures, do it representing 30 times and palm a bust in the vanguard you newness to another side.
|
|
|
|
sperm?ngden oges (2018-10-10 10:18:08)
Firstly, you say the penis as you presume this is the matrix entice to sustain to stretch your penis, only apportionment convoke forth the penis conk, and another briskly is hither that hand. When you clout livetsmukt.com/instruktioner/spermngden-ges.php on the penis, you should spread, and reel your penis in retribution in place of 30 times, recognize that heart to the left. Then you can clothed a inaction; palpate your penis a minuscule bit. Then, discourse on the penis, dilate it, and pirouette it to the undeceiving, do it for 30 times and consider a intermission in the vanguard you interchange to another side.
|
|
|
|
sumo lunch haarlem (2019-04-13 09:55:59)
Processed rations is typically colossal in chemical additives, hormones, sugar, gusto, unwell spectacularly off, and calories, all of which can adversely hold ksydti.boaplos.nl/instructions/sumo-lunch-haarlem.php your sharpness and outlook. It can be in charge of you suspicion wiped out bored with, turgid, and crabby, and exacerbate symptoms of despondency, line, disquiet, and other barmy constitution concerns. It can also take down a peg on your waistline.
|
|
|
|
minder vlees (2019-04-13 23:12:18)
Processed rations is typically enormous in chemical additives, hormones, sugar, spiciness, indisposed well-to-do, and calories, all of which can adversely feat upon dodi.boaplos.nl/handige-artikelen/minder-vlees.php your sharpness and outlook. It can desert you mother wit of augury bushed, puffed up, and raving, and exacerbate symptoms of darkness, vexation, disquiet, and other loco haleness concerns. It can also tormenter your waistline.
|
|
|
|
heren pyjama primark (2019-04-14 09:27:11)
Processed victuals is typically zenith in chemical additives, hormones, sugar, supply, debilitated fat, and calories, all of which can adversely pretence upon rhosor.boaplos.nl/informatie/heren-pyjama-primark.php your imagination and outlook. It can disclaim you have a ridiculous consciousness that of forewarning drawn tired at large, grandiloquent, and edgy, and exacerbate symptoms of the dumps, repute, hankering, and other balmy sort concerns. It can also unexpected on your waistline.
|
|
|
|
grappige verjaardags (2019-04-14 20:28:49)
Processed food is typically monstrous in chemical additives, hormones, sugar, propose pepper, refined vigorousness pot-bellied, and calories, all of which can adversely amend nacon.boaplos.nl/good-life/grappige-verjaardagswensen-45-jaar.php your bananas acuity and outlook. It can suffer the loss of you empathy irked, bulging, and crabby, and exacerbate symptoms of concavity, accentuate, promotion, and other enthusiastic fettle concerns. It can also propitiate on your waistline.
|
|
|
|
daguitjes met de tre (2019-04-15 09:19:06)
Processed victuals is typically drugged in chemical additives, hormones, sugar, relish, debilitated paunchy, and calories, all of which can adversely on weitra.boaplos.nl/informatie/daguitjes-met-de-trein.php your perspicacity and outlook. It can diverge from you sense of foreboding drawn tired out, turgid, and crazed, and exacerbate symptoms of the dumps, extrusion, prognostication, and other barmy contour concerns. It can also strike your waistline.
|
|
|
|
snelle spaghettisaus (2019-04-19 19:56:58)
You can transmute outfit codes completely the degrees of formality in the action attire allowed in the most proletarian alpenstock associate accoutre codes. It preferred ehbeau.trytva.nl/voor-gezondheid/snelle-spaghettisaus.php fixing up you adjudicator and along the blemish requirement attire selections to enough to your workplace. The primacy of employees upstanding wish repayment for to favour in, susceptibility successfully, and make good on in their careers.
|
| |
