|
|
|
| | |
|  | |
| | |
|
이상한 나라의 진중권 03
|
|
- 전진
|
더욱 심각한 문제는 진중권 씨가 당의 ‘이념감독관’으로서 “사회주의자들”이라 판정한 전진은 사회주의자들이 아니라는 사실이다. 사회주의에 대해 조갑제 이상의 반감을 가진(이 부분은 뒤에서 다시 적기로) 진중권 씨의 눈에는 전진과 그들의 문건이 ‘완전 사회주의’로 보일 수도 있지만, 애석하게도 전진은 사회주의자가 아니라 사민주의자들이다. 자본주의 모순을 체제 변혁을 통해 이루려는 사람들이 아니라 체제 안에서(의회 진출과 복지 증진 등으로) 극복하려는 사람들이다. 전진은 진보신당의 정체성을 보편적으로 담고 있는 그룹인 것이다.
한국의 좌파들은 크게 진보정당(민노당, 진보신당)에 참여한 그룹과 참여하지 않은 좀더 급진적인 그룹으로 나눌 수 있다. 그렇게 좌파진영 전체를 놓고 볼 때 전진은 가장 오른쪽의, 온건한 그룹에 속한다. 실제로 좀더 급진적인 경향의 좌파들 가운데는 ‘전진도 좌파야?’ 식의 냉소적인 태도를 보이는 경우도 있다. 그런 전진이 진보신당에서 해체하거나 나가야 할 낡은 사회주의자들이라면 대체 진보신당의 정체성은 뭐가 되어야 할까? ‘진보정당이길 포기하고 자유주의 정당이 되어야 한다’는 주장과 다를 바 없다.
설사, 전진이 진중권 씨 주장에 합치하는 낡은 사회주의자들이라 하더라도 누구도 그들에게 나가거나 해체하라고 요구할 권리가 없다. 전진이 당의 민주주의를 존중하며 비판과 토론을 통해 자신들의 정체성을 표현한다면 말이다. 민주주의란 다른 사람과의 차이를 서로 존중하면서 비판과 토론을 통해 좀더 나은 결과를 찾아나가는 사회 원리이다. 그래서 민주주의 사회는 다른 사람과의 차이를 존중하지 않고 배타적이고 폭력적인 태도에 반대한다. 우리가 우파를 존중하지만 극우는 사회의 적이라 생각하는 이유는 바로 그래서다.
진중권 씨는 자신이 “천성이 리버럴해서 국가가 개인의 권리에 침해하는 걸 못 봐주는 편”이라고 했다. 좋은 이야기고, 나 역시 그렇다. 그런데 그럼 사람이라면, 국가가 어떻고 이전에 다른 개인의 권리를 존중할 줄 알아야 할 것이다. 다른 사람의 사유와 상상력을 검열하여 이념을 재단하고 나가라 사라져라 요구하는 사람이 “타고난 리버럴이라 국가가 개인에 간섭하는 꼴을 못본다”고 말하는 건 해괴한 일이다. 사실 그런 태도는 2010년의 한국에선 한나라당에서도 찾아보기 어려운, 조갑제나 지만원 같은 아예 내놓은 극우 인사들에게서나 볼 수 있는 것이다. 그런 사람을 "진보신당 당적의 자유주의자"라 부르는 건 모욕적인 딱지붙이기일까, 과분한 상찬일까?
김규항 <고래가 그랬어> 발행인
2010/08/16 |
|
|
|
|
 wq (2018-01-05 14:22:09)
http://www.burberbags.co.uk/, http://www.jerseys-store.com/, http://azcardinals.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.outlet-ralphlaurenpolo.com/, http://www.vibram--fivefingers.com/, http://www.marc-jacobs.us.com/, http://www.vans-shoesoutlet.co.uk/, http://www.nike-free5.com/, http://www.newbalanceschuhe.com.de/, http://www.ralph-laurens-outlet.com/, http://www.under-armouroutlet.com/, http://www.the-northface.ca/, http://www.hermes-birkinoutlet.com/, http://www.beatsbydrephone.com/, http://www.versace-outletonline.com/, http://raiders.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.outlet-toryburch.com/, http://www.oakleysunglasses.org.es/, http://www.dsquared2s.com/, http://coachoutlet.euro-us.net/, http://www.timberlandspaschere.fr/, http://www.canada-michaelkors.ca/, http://panthers.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.woolrich-jackets.com/, http://www.outlet-mkors.com/, http://www.new-balanceshoes.es/, http://www.polos-outlet.us.com/, http://www.uhren-stores.de/, http://www.michaelkorsoutlet.mex.com/, http://www.rl-ralphlauren.co.uk/, http://www.birkenstockshoes.com.de/, http://www.christianlouboutinoutlet.net.co/, http://www.cheapshoes.net.co/, http://www.nike-airmaxs.fr/, http://www.raybans-glasses.com.co/, http://www.philipp-pleins.com/, http://www.ralphlaurens.com.de/, http://www.armani-outlet.com/, http://www.nikeroshe-run.com.es/, http://www.outlet-pradas.com/, http://www.nikeairmax.com.de/, http://www.coachoutlet-usa.com/, http://www.ralphs-laurenpolos.co.uk/, http://www.nike-shoesoutlet.us.org/, http://clippers.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.nike-factory.com.co/, http://www.nike-shoesoutlet.com/, http://www.airmax-shoes.com/, http://ravens.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.rayban-sunglasses.fr/, http://jazz.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://browns.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://bears.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.adidassuper-star.com.de/, http://www.barbours.us.com/, http://cowboys.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://mavericks.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://falcons.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.coachoutlet-coachoutletonline.com/, http://bengals.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.montblancpen-sale.com/, http://jaguars.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.babylisspros.com/, http://www.nike-shoes.com.co/, http://www.cheap-raybansoutlet.com.co/, http://www.valentino-shoesoutlet.us.com/, http://michaelkors.euro-us.net/, http://www.rayban-sunglasses.co/, http://www.mcm-handbags.com.co/, http://www.rolexwatchesforsale.us.com/, http://www.mk-com.com/, http://www.fendi-outlet.in.net/, http://www.jimmychoos-shoes.com/, http://lakers.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://bills.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.sunglasses-oakleys.com.co/, http://www.coach-outlet.store/, http://www.pandora-jewelry.top/, http://www.watches-omega.com/, http://www.thenorth-face.com.co/, http://www.michaelkorsoutlet.se/, http://www.swarovskijewellery-au.com/, http://www.hogans.com.de/, http://www.retrojordan-shoes.com/, http://www.hugo-boss.com.co/, http://www.nikerosherun.com.co/, http://grizzlies.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.nike-shoes.org.es/, http://www.kate-spade-outlet.us.com/, http://cavaliers.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.mizuno-running.net/, http://www.nike-airmax.com.co/, http://www.christian-louboutins.us.com/, http://www.burbagsoutlet.com/, http://pacers.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.polosoutlet-store.com/, http://www.puma-shoes.com.de/, http://eagles.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.ralphs-laurenspolos.com/, http://www.hollisterclothingcanada.ca/, http://www.cheap-jerseys.mex.com/, http://www.michaelkors.so/, http://www.vansshoes-outlet.com/, http://www.nike-shoesstore.com/, http://www.michael-kors-bags.us.org/, http://www.long-champhandbags.com/, http://warriors.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.raybans-cher.fr/, http://nuggets.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.watch-rolex.co.uk/, http://www.air-maxschoenen.co.nl/, http://www.rolex-watchescanada.ca/, http://www.oakleys-sunglasses.com.co/, http://www.the-northfacejackets.net.co/, http://www.juicy-coutureoutlet.com/, http://www.marcjacobs-outlet.com/, http://www.rosherun-shoes.co.uk/, http://www.ralphlaurens-polos.com/, http://www.mcm-handbags.org/, http://www.outlet-michaelkors-online.com/, http://suns.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://heat.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://pistons.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.eyeglassesinsale.com/, http://www.swarovskionlineshop.com.de/, http://www.hollister-store.com.co/, http://www.hermesoutlet.shop/, http://www.raybansbocco.it/, http://www.soccers-shoes.us.com/, http://www.northfacejackets.fr/, http://www.clothes-outlet-store.com/, http://www.nikefreerun-inc.co.uk/, http://www.michaels-kors.co.uk/, http://www.oakley-sbocco.it/, http://www.timberlandboots-outlet.com/, http://www.longchamp-outlet.com.co/, http://trailblazers.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.timberland-boots.com.co/, http://www.supra-footwear.net/, http://www.nbateamonline.com/, http://www.michaelkors.com.de/, http://www.nike-free-runs.de/, http://www.skechers-shoesoutlet.com/, http://www.outletonline-michael-kors.co.uk/, http://www.nike-shoes.co.nl/, http://www.okglassesale.com/, http://titans.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.tracksuits.com.co/, http://www.nike-free-runs.com/, http://www.true-religions.com/, http://www.jordan.com.de/, http://www.tommy-hilfigers.de/, http://www.dsquared2-outlet.com/, http://www.cheap-jordans.com.co/, http://www.thomassabos-jewelrys.co.uk/, http://www.true-religionsoutlet.com/, http://www.nikeairmax-isc.co.uk/, http://www.christian-louboutin.jp.net/, http://www.skechers-canada.ca/, http://www.ralphlauren-au.com/, http://www.air-yeezyshoes.com/, http://www.asicsoutlet.net/, http://www.adidasshoes.com.se/, http://www.mlb-jerseys.org/, http://www.barbours-factory.com/, http://www.raybanoutlet.ca/, http://www.bottega-venetasoutlet.com/, http://www.bcbg-canada.ca/, http://www.jeans-truereligion.com/, http://www.barboursjackets.com/, http://colts.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.montrespaschers.fr/, http://www.christianlouboutin-shoes.ca/, http://dolphins.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.cc-beanies.us.com/, http://bucks.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.swarovskis-sale.co.uk/, http://steelers.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.oakleys-frames.com/, http://www.hollister.com.se/, http://www.louboutinshoes.jp.net/, http://www.north-faceoutletjacket.com/, http://www.rolex-watches.us.com/, http://www.cheap-mlbjerseys.us.com/, http://www.hogan-shoes.co.uk/, http://www.tommyhilfigerca.ca/, http://www.salomonshoes.com.de/, http://www.timberland-shoes.com.co/, http://www.cheap-juicycouture.com/, http://www.nba-shoes.com/, http://www.burberrys-handbags.com.co/, http://www.ralphlauren.mex.com/, http://www.designer-handbagsoutlet.us.com/, http://www.airhuarache-inc.co.uk/, http://www.giuseppezanotti.com.co/, http://www.converses-outlet.com/, http://www.longchamps-bags.us.com/, http://www.replica-handbags.us.com/, http://www.coachoutlet-online.com.co/, http://www.coach-outlet.net.in/, http://www.scarpe-hoganshoes.it/, http://www.mbt-shoesoutlet.com/, http://www.kate-spades.net/, http://www.rosherun-shoes.us/, http://www.bcbg-dresses.net/, http://www.airjordans-shoes.com/, http://www.polo-ralphlaurens.us.com/, http://www.cheap-baseballbats.us/, http://www.nikerosherun.com.de/, http://hawks.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.pandorajewellery-au.com/, http://www.raybans-outlet.com.co/, http://www.outlet-tommy-hilfiger.com/, http://www.nikeair-max.ca/, http://www.mizuno.us.com/, http://www.outlet-true-religion.us.org/, http://www.poloralphlauren.com.de/, http://www.airhuarache-shoes.co.uk/, http://kings.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.swarovski-canada.ca/, http://www.basketballshoes.com.co/, http://www.outlet-pradahandbags.com/, http://wizards.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.hollister.com.de/, http://www.michael-korsoutletonline.com.co/, http://www.outletonline-ralphlauren.com/, http://www.cheap-iphone-cases.com/, http://www.coach-outlets.net.co/, http://www.thomassabo.us.com/, http://www.beatsheadphone.in.net/, http://www.michaelkorsoutlet.online/, http://www.pandora-charmscanada.ca/, http://www.oakleysunglasses-canada.ca/, http://www.airmax.com.se/, http://www.celinefactory.com/, http://seahawks.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.monclers-outlet.us.com/, http://www.cheap-nike-shoes.com/, http://www.omegas-relojes.es/, http://www.philipppleins.com/, http://www.reeboks.com.de/, http://www.barbour-jackets.in.net/, http://www.outlet-michaelkors.com/, http://www.long-champ.com.co/, http://lions.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.nfljerseys-sale.com/, http://www.nikeshoes-canada.ca/, http://www.outletonlineburberrybags.com/, http://www.calvin-klein.com.co/, http://www.cheap-jerseys.com.co/, http://www.mcm-backpacks.com.co/, http://www.oakleys.mex.com/, http://www.burberry-storevip.com/, http://www.ray-bans.org.es/, http://www.michael-korsbags.com.co/, http://www.adidas-shoesoutlet.com/, http://giants.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://broncos.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.kate-spadebags.com/, http://www.handbagsoutlet.in.net/, http://www.airmax2015.net/, http://www.burberoutlet.co.uk/, http://www.soccershoes.us.com/, http://www.christian-louboutin-shoes.com/, http://www.nike-shoes-outlet.co.uk/, http://www.beats-by-dre.com.co/, http://www.bottega-bags.com/, http://www.fred-perrys.co.uk/, http://packers.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.cheap-michaelkors.com.co/, http://www.adidas-shoes.es/, http://www.soccershoes-outlet.com/, http://www.burberry-outlets.ca/, http://www.katespades.com.co/, http://www.jewelrys-swarovski.com/, http://jets.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.oakleys-sunglass.com.co/, http://www.oakleys-online.com.co/, http://www.cheap-watches.in.net/, http://www.converse-shoes.net/, http://www.rayban-wear.co.uk/, http://www.raybans-outlet.co.nl/, http://www.instylers.us/, http://www.danskoshoes.in.net/, http://www.chiflatironhair.us.com/, http://www.iphone-cases.net/, http://www.pradas.com.de/, http://www.horlogesrolexs.co.nl/, http://www.salvatoreferragamo.us.com/, http://www.ok-em.com/, http://www.ed-hardy.us.com/, http://nets.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.michael-korsukpurse.co.uk/, http://www.adidas-store.net/, http://www.chiflatiron-hair.com/, http://vikings.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.adidas-shoes.co.nl/, http://www.north-face-jackets.org.uk/, http://www.fredperrypolos.co.uk/, http://www.tommy-hilfigers.com.co/, http://www.north-face.com.co/, http://www.hollister-clothings.us.com/, http://www.christian-louboutins.com/, http://www.burberoutlet.com/, http://www.outlet-raybans.co.uk/, http://www.the-northface.in.net/, http://www.oakleysoutlet.com.co/, http://www.cheapnhljerseys.us.com/, http://timberwolves.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.ferragamo.net.co/, http://www.airjordanshoes.com.co/, http://www.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.outlet-pradabags.com/, http://www.nikeairforce.com.de/, http://www.rl-ralphlaurenpolos.co.uk/, http://www.converse-schuhe.com.de/, http://www.pandora-jewelry.com.de/, http://www.outletburberry-bags.com/, http://www.australia-oakleysunglasses.com/, http://www.new-balanceshoes.com/, http://buccaneers.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.cheapomega-watches.com/, http://www.jordan-retros.com/, http://www.moncler-jackets.com.co/, http://www.coachblackfriday.com/, http://www.burberbags.com/, http://www.raybans-outlet.cc/, http://www.monclers-outlet.us.com/, http://www.replica-handbags.com.co/, http://www.chrome-heartoutlet.com/, http://saints.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.outlet-toryburchshoes.com/, http://www.ray-bans.net.co/, http://www.zcoachoutlet.com/, http://www.nike-paschers.fr/, http://www.converse-shoes-outlet.com/, http://www.raybansasses.com/, http://www.softballbats-sale.com/, http://www.birkenstocks.com.de/, http://www.mcm-bagsoutlet.com/, http://www.nike-maxshoes.fr/, http://www.outlet-michaelkors.us.org/, http://www.hollister-outlet.com/, http://www.ferragamo-inc.co.uk/, http://knicks.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.outlet-ralphlaurens.com/, http://www.nikefreeshoes-inc.co.uk/, http://www.jimmychoo-shoes.com/, http://spurs.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.oakley-outletonline.com.co/, http://www.nike-skos.com/, http://www.oakley-sunglassessale.com.co/, http://www.eccoshoesoutlet.com/, http://www.airmax-90.com/, http://www.oakestore.com/, http://www.outlet-ralphlauren.co.uk/, http://www.hollister-clothings-store.com/, http://www.the-northface.com.de/, http://www.burberry-store.com/, http://www.raybans.com.de/, http://raptors.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.polos-ralphlauren.com.co/, http://www.michael-kors.net.co/, http://www.nike-huarache.co.nl/, http://www.burberryoutlet-sale.net.co/, http://celtics.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.ralphlauren-canada.ca/, http://www.australia-michaelkors.com/, http://redskins.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.outlet-pumashoes.com/, http://www.nike-store.com.de/, http://www.long-champ.com.de/, http://www.rolexwatch-outlet.com/, http://www.nike-airmax.com.de/, http://www.barbour-jackets.us.com/, http://www.adidas-shoes.ca/, http://www.montblancpences.com/, http://www.fidgetspinner.us.com/, http://www.tommy-hilfigers.net.co/, http://www.supra-footwears.com/, http://www.ralphlauren-polos.com.co/, http://www.tommyhilfigers.co.nl/, http://www.nike-shoes.co/, http://www.coach-factoryoutlet.net.co/, http://www.pandoracharms-inc.co.uk/, http://www.nikeairmax-australia.com/, http://www.coachsoutletonline.in.net/, http://www.nikeshoes.de/, http://www.ray-bansoutlet.com.co/, http://www.hoodies-factory.com/, http://www.jerseys.net.in/, http://rockets.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.michael-kors.com.es/, http://www.nikeair-max.es/, http://texans.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.michaelkors-ins.com/, http://www.lonchamp.us.com/, http://www.coach-factory.com.co/, http://magic.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.prada-shoes.us.org/, http://www.birkenstock.net.in/, http://www.nike-shoes.com.se/, http://www.oakley-outlet.fr/, http://76ers.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.asicsoutlet.com.co/, http://www.newbalance-canada.ca/, http://www.raybans-outlet.net.co/, http://www.coachfactory.cc/, http://www.nhl-jerseys.com/, http://49ers.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://bulls.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.tommyhilfigers.de/, http://chargers.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.adidasschuhe-online.com.de/, http://www.giuseppes-zanottishoes.com/, http://www.lacosteoutlet.com.co/, http://www.michael-kors.cc/, http://www.coachfactory.shop/, http://patriots.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.michaelkors.co.nl/, http://www.outlet-true-religion.com/, http://chiefs.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.vansschuhe.com.de/, http://www.hermesbagsoutlet.com/, http://www.burberrys-outletonline.in.net/, http://www.oakleys-outlets.net/, http://www.new-balanceoutlet.org/, http://www.beatsbydre.com.co/, http://www.crystals-swarovskis.com/, http://www.nike-mercurial.com/, http://www.burberryoutletonline.com.de/, http://www.ferragamos.us.com/, http://www.levis-jeansoutlet.com/, http://rams.nfl-jerseys.org/, http://www.thomas-sabos.com.de/, http://www.lauren-ralphs-outlet.co.uk/, http://www.truereligions.net/, http://www.co-aol.com/, http://www.reebok-shoes.co.uk/, http://www.nike-rosherun.co.nl/, http://coach.euro-us.net/, http://www.coachoutletonlinemall.com/, http://www.oakleysunglasses-lrc.com/, http://www.givenchy.com.co/, http://hornets.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.skechers-outlet.com/, http://www.mcmbackpacks.com.co/, http://www.jackets-thenorthface.com/, http://www.fitflop-outlet.com/, http://www.michaels-korsoutlet.com/, http://www.versaceoutlet.us.com/, http://www.oakleys.com.de/, http://www.christian-louboutinshoesoutlet.com/, http://www.coach-outletonline.ca/, http://www.pandora-jewellery.com.es/, http://www.salvatore-ferragamos.com/, http://thunder.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.long-champ-outlet.com/, http://pelicans.nbajerseysstore.com/, http://www.stone-islandestore.com/
|
 |
|
|
|
